The reality is the NPS as it stands today is anything but the wonderful old-age security that it is made out to be! In theory there is much to commend the NPS. Increasing longevity and a growing fiscal deficit leave the government with no alternative but to devise ways to enable people to take care of themselves in their own age. Add to this the fact that pension funds are a ready source for investment in long-term infrastructure projects and we have a cast-iron case for NPS.
Do we really? Why am I a critic of the NPS? Because the scheme as it stands today is deeply flawed.
To start with, in most countries where we have similar schemes, the NPS or its clone constitutes a second tier with the State providing a basic Tier 1 out of taxpayer funds. In the absence of a meaningful Tier 1 in India, the NPS alone is supposed to keep its subscribers from destitution.