PCDA FAQ on Rank Pay Matter
Q. How has the pay been revised on 01/01/86?
Ans. The following example illustrates the method of pay revision as per the judgment of Hon’ble SC.
Q.2 Ans. | I was Lt. Col. as on 01-01-1986 and retired on 01-08-95. I was promoted to the rank of Col on 05-06-1986 and Brig on 03-06-92. Therefore, I am entitled to get arrears of Rank pay @ Rs. 800/- per month w.e.f. 01-01-86 to 04-06-86, Some aspects to be made clear here-
E.g. | |||
Officer is Lt Col as on 01.01.86 | ||||
Effective Date & Casualty | Before Revision | After Revision | ||
01-01-86 (4th CPC) | 4050 + 800 | 4650 + 800 | ||
01-06-86 (Incr) | 4200 + 800 | 4800 + 800 | ||
05-06-86 (Prom to Col) | 4500 + 1000 | 4800 + 1000 | ||
01-06-87 (Incr) | 4650 + 1000 | 4950 + 1000 | ||
01-06-88 (Incr) | 4800 + 1000 | 5100 + 1000 | ||
01-06-89 (Incr) | 4950 + 1000 | 5100 + 1000 | ||
01-06-90 (Incr) | 5100 + 1000 | 5100 + 1000 + 150(Stag) | ||
01-06-91 (Incr) | 5100 + 1000 | 5100 + 1000 + 150(Stag) | ||
01-06-92 (Incr) | 5100 + 1000 + 150(Stag) | 5100 + 1000 + 200(Stag) | ||
03-06-92 (Prom of Brig) | 5100 + 1200 | 5100 + 1200 | ||
Note 1
| Even though Rank Pay corresponding to the rank held by the officer on 01/01/86 is Rs 800/-, the difference officer gets now is only Rs 600/- When the officer gets promotion to Colonel, his pay doesn’t get any hike (after revision now) as he was already drawing more than the minimum admissible to Colonel. Pay in the revised scale and pre-revised scale becomes equal on the date of promotion of Brig. i.e. 03-06-92 in this case. Hence, no further arrears are admissible thereafter. It is evident that with every promotion, the difference in Revised & Pre-revised Pay is reducing. | |||
Q.3 Ans | Why no further increments have been admitted to me in ‘Revised Pay’ after my Basic Pay reached the scale of Rs. 5100/- w.e.f. 01-06-89 ? My Rank at that time was Lt. Col. During 4th CPC, Rs. 5100/- was the maximum scale admissible for the Ranks from Major to Brig. Maximum scale for Maj. Gen was Rs. 6700/- In case the Basic pay of any officer of the rank of Major, Lt Col or Col reached Rs. 5100/- during 4th CPC, i.e. between 01-01-86 to 31-12-95, the officer was entitled for only two Stagnation Increments which were admissible only after every two years. The rates of Stagnation Increments were Rs. 150/- and Rs. 200/- only. In case of Brigadier, three Stagnation Increments were admissible @ Rs. 200/-, Rs. 300/- and Rs. 400/-. | |||
E.g. | |||||||||||||||
(i) | In the case of Maj, Lt. Col. & Col.- | ||||||||||||||
In the revised scale, if the officer reached Rs. 5100/- w.e.f. 01-06-89, | |||||||||||||||
(II) | In the case of Brigadier- | ||||||||||||||
In the revised scale, if the officer reached Rs. 5100/- w.e.f. 01-06-89, | |||||||||||||||
Q.4 Ans. | I and my batch-mate were both commissioned on the same date i.e. 20-12-70 and both were holding the rank of Major as on 01-01-1986. But I have been paid The arrears of Rank pay in respect of two Officers with the same Date of Commission and same rank as on 01-01-86 may differ due to
In general, officers who got better promotions have been drawing more pay. Likelihood of the difference getting nullified before retirement in his case is much more than that in case of officer who got less/late promotions. | ||||||||||||||
Illustration: | |||||||||||||||
(i) | Officer ‘X’ | ||||||||||||||
Sr. No. | Effective Date | Casualty | Drawn (Old Pay) | Due (New Pay) | |||||||||||
Basic Pay | Rank Pay | Basic Pay | Rank Pay | ||||||||||||
1. | 01.01.86 | 4CPC | 3400 | 600 | 3900 | 600 | |||||||||
2. | 01.03.86 | Incr (Step-up) | 3500 | 600 | 4050 | 600 | |||||||||
3. | 01.03.87 | Incr | 3600 | 600 | 4200 | 600 | |||||||||
4. | 01.03.88 | Incr | 3700 | 600 | 4350 | 600 | |||||||||
5. | 20.08.88 | SUBPROM | 3900 | 800 | 4350 | 800 | |||||||||
6. | 01.03.89 | Incr (New scale) | 3900 | 800 | 4500 | 800 | |||||||||
7. | 01.08.89 | Incr (Old scale) | 4050 | 800 | 4500 | 800 | |||||||||
8. | 01.03.90 | Incr (New scale) | 4050 | 800 | 4650 | 800 | |||||||||
9. | 01.08.90 | Incr(Old scale) | 4200 | 800 | 4650 | 800 | |||||||||
11. | 01.03.91 | Incr (New scale) | 4200 | 800 | 4800 | 800 | |||||||||
12. | 10.06.91 | SUBPROM | 4500 | 1000 | 4800 | 1000 | |||||||||
13. | 01.03.92 | Incr (New scale) | 4500 | 1000 | 4950 | 1000 | |||||||||
14. | 01.06.92 | Incr (Old scale) | 4650 | 1000 | 4950 | 1000 | |||||||||
15. | 01.03.93 | Incr (New scale) | 4650 | 1000 | 5100 | 1000 | |||||||||
16. | 01.06.93 | Incr (Old scale) | 4800 | 1000 | 5100 | 1000 | |||||||||
17. | 01.06.94 | Incr (Old scale) | 4950 | 1000 | 5100 | 1000 | |||||||||
18. | 01.03.95 | Stag Incr (New scale) | 4950 | 1000 | 5100+150 | 1000 | |||||||||
19. | 01.06.95 | Incr (Old scale) | 5100 | 1000 | 5100+150 | 1000 | |||||||||
20. | 01.01.96 | 5CPC | 15550 | 2000 | 15550 | 2000 | |||||||||
Total Arrears – Rs 62,145/- | |||||||||||||||
(ii) | Officer ‘Y’ | ||||||||||||||
Sr. No. | Effective Date | Casualty | Drawn (Old Pay) | Due (New Pay) | |||||||||||
Basic Pay | Rank Pay | Basic Pay | Rank Pay | ||||||||||||
1. | 01.01.86 | 4CPC | 3400 | 600 | 3900 | 600 | |||||||||
2. | 01.03.86 | Incr (Step-up) | 3500 | 600 | 4050 | 600 | |||||||||
3. | 01.03.87 | Incr | 3600 | 600 | 4200 | 600 | |||||||||
4. | 01.03.88 | Incr | 3700 | 600 | 4350 | 600 | |||||||||
5. | 01.03.89 | Incr | 3800 | 600 | 4500 | 600 | |||||||||
6. | 01.03.90 | Incr | 3900 | 600 | 4650 | 600 | |||||||||
7. | 25.08.90 | SUBPROM | 3900 | 800 | 4650 | 800 | |||||||||
8. | 01.03.91 | Incr | 4050 | 800 | 4800 | 800 | |||||||||
9. | 01.03.92 | Incr | 4200 | 800 | 4950 | 800 | |||||||||
10. | 01.03.93 | Incr | 4350 | 800 | 5100 | 800 | |||||||||
11. | 01.03.94 | Incr (Old scale) | 4500 | 800 | 5100 | 800 | |||||||||
12. | 01.03.95 | Stag Incr (New scale) | 4650 | 800 | 5100+150 | 800 | |||||||||
13. | 01.01.96 | 5CPC | 13900 | 1600 | 14700 | 1600 | |||||||||
14. | 01.03.96 | Incr | 14300 | 1600 | 15100 | 1600 | |||||||||
15. | 01.03.97 | Incr | 14700 | 1600 | 15500 | 1600 | |||||||||
16. | 01.03.98 | Incr | 15100 | 1600 | 15900 | 1600 | |||||||||
17. | 01.03.99 | Incr | 15500 | 1600 | 16300 | 1600 | |||||||||
18. | 01.03.00 | Incr | 15900 | 1600 | 16700 | 1600 | |||||||||
19. | 01.03.01 | Incr | 16300 | 1600 | 17100 | 1600 | |||||||||
20. | 01.02.02 | Retire | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||||||||
Total Arrears – Rs. 1,96,878/- | |||||||||||||||
NOTE: | In the first illustration, the difference in Pre-revised and Revised pay becomes zero on 01-01-96, i.e. the effect terminates w.e.f. 01-01-96; whereas in the second illustration, the difference in Pre-revised and Revised pay continues post 5th CPC till the date of retirement. Consequently, in the 2nd illustration the amount of Encashment of leave will also undergo a change as last Basic Pay before retirement has undergone a change. | ||||||||||||||
Q.5 Ans. | Why the difference of Pay in my case is decreasing every year post 01-01-86 as per the ‘Due-Drawn’ statement issued to me? During 4th CPC, if the officer’s Basic Pay at the time of promotion was less than the minimum of Basic Pay of the next Rank, his Basic Pay was upgraded to the minimum of next Rank. But if his Basic Pay had already crossed the minimum of Basic Pay of the next Rank, his pay would not increase on promotion. In that condition he would get only Rank Pay of next Rank. Illustration: | ||||||||||||||
Basic Pay of Major ‘X’ at the time of promotion to Lt Col = Rs 3700 On promotion to Lt Col, Basic Pay admissible = Rs 3900 Basic Pay of Major ‘Y’ at the time of promotion to Lt Col = Rs 4050 On promotion to Lt Col, Basic Pay admissible = Rs 4050 (no change) | |||||||||||||||
Basic Pay of Lt Col ‘A’ at the time of promotion to Col =Rs 4350 On promotion to Col, Basic Pay admissible = Rs 4500 Basic Pay of Lt Col ‘B’ at the time of promotion to Col =Rs 4800 On promotion to Col, Basic Pay admissible = Rs 4800 (no change) Since the pay-revision as per the court judgment, in many cases, results into the officer crossing the minimum of the pay of the next rank, his pay (in ‘due after revision’) does not get any increase, whereas he might have got (in ‘drawn before revision’) a jump to the minimum of the next rank. Thus the difference between ‘Due now’ and the ‘Drawn earlier’ becomes less. | |||||||||||||||
Q.6 Ans. | Why Income Tax on my arrears has been calculated @ 20%, whereas other Officers’ arrears have been paid after deducting Income Tax at only 10% rate. In case PAN of Officer has been received in the office of PCDA (O), the IT deduction has been calculated @ 10%. Since your PAN has not been received in this office, I.T. has been deducted @ 20% in your case. In all such cases, officers are requested to claim the same from IT Department after filing IT return. | ||||||||||||||
Q.7 Ans. | When will I receive my Form-16 (Tax deduction at Source Certificate) regarding payment of arrears? The generation of Form-16 regarding payment of arrears is under process. The same will be uploaded on the website in due course. | ||||||||||||||
Q.8 Ans. | Are the Officers, in receipt of Gallantary Awards/Disability Pension/Tribal Officer residing in North East Region, entitled for exemption in Income Tax on arrears of Rank Pay at source? No. The exemption in Income Tax at source cannot be allowed on payment of arrears of ‘Rank Pay’. The refund of Income Tax may be claimed from IT Department after filing IT return. | ||||||||||||||
Q.9 Ans. | Why have the Gratuity and Encashment of leave on retirement not been revised while calculating the arrears of Rank Pay ? The Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity is payable by PCDA (P), Allahabad and hence will be revised by them. | ||||||||||||||
The Encashment of leave has been revised by PCDA (O) in all affected cases. However, the difference in amount of Encashment of leave is admissible only in cases where the difference in ‘Due Pay’ and ‘Drawn Pay’ continues till the date of retirement. In case the ‘Due Pay’ and ‘Drawn Pay’ of an Officer reaches same stage any time before retirement (i.e. on any date of promotion OR on 01-01-96 OR on 01-01-2006), there will be no change in the amount of Leave Encashment already paid. | |||||||||||||||
Q.10 Ans. | When will my LPC-cum-Data sheet be revised and sent to PCDA (P), Allahabad for revision in PPO ? The revised LPC-cum-Data sheet will be forwarded to PCDA (P), Allahabad shortly. However, the same is not applicable in all cases. In case there is no difference in ‘Due pay’ and ‘Drawn Pay’ at the time of retirement, no revision will be required to be carried out in the original LPC-cum-Data sheet. Accordingly, PPO will also not to be revised in such cases. | ||||||||||||||
Q.11 Ans. | I have not got arrears for the period of Re-employment? No arrears have yet been calculated for the period of re-employment. Separate action in respect of Re-employed officers will be taken. | ||||||||||||||
Q.12 Ans. | Has part payment been made by PCDA(O) because the amount admitted to me seems to be very little? No. the arrears have been calculated and paid in full to each and every officer. | ||||||||||||||
Q.13 Ans. | My ‘Drawn statement’ uploaded on the website is incorrect as it differs from the actual drawn pay as per original statements of accounts available with me. How will this be rectified? The ‘Drawn statement’ of all the officers are being reviewed and in case there is any discrepancy due to technical reasons, the same are being rectified suo-motto. The Officers are requested to wait for the revised ‘Due-Drawn’ statements which will be uploaded on website in due course. | ||||||||||||||
Q.14 Ans. | It has been intimated that my IRLA has been destroyed in PCDA (O) Office after expiry of retention period. What action will now be taken regarding payment of my arrears? Some data required for calculation of arrears in case of Officers, whose IRLAs have been destroyed, has been received from IHQ of MOD (Army). Since the data is not sufficient for calculation of arrears, a proposal for approach to be adopted in such cases is under consideration of MOD. Orders of MOD are expected soon. Action will be taken on receipt of orders | ||||||||||||||
copyright PCDA(O) Pune 2013 ©
