New Delhi, September 5, 2023 - In a significant development, the Delhi High Court has issued a strict ultimatum, setting a seven-week deadline for the Central government to execute a judgment handed down last year. This judgment mandates the extension of House Rent Allowance (HRA) benefits to all personnel serving in paramilitary forces, regardless of their rank. The case in question, titled Aarif Hussain Versus Shri Ajay Kumar Bhalla And Ors, has been a subject of contention for several months.
Justice Jasmeet Singh delivered the ruling on August 29, expressing deep concern over repeated instances where the court's directives and timelines were disregarded by relevant authorities. The court had initially granted the Central government, including the Union Ministry of Home Affairs and the Ministry of Finance, a six-week period to comply with its directive. However, it was discovered that the order remained unimplemented for more than nine months, prompting the court to take action.
Justice Singh emphasized that the mere filing of an appeal before the Supreme Court should not be used as an excuse for non-compliance with the court's order. He underscored that the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), as a security force, is not exempt from the jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court. The court noted the complete lack of adherence to its directions and timelines and warned that if the orders were not executed as specified within seven weeks, the CRPF would be required to appear in court on the next hearing date.
Upon the request of the counsel representing the Union government, the court generously granted a seven-week window for compliance with its earlier judgment issued on December 15, 2022. This directive was issued in response to a contempt petition that alleged a failure to adhere to the December 2022 judgment.
The December 2022 judgment, delivered by a division bench comprising Justices Suresh Kumar Kait and Saurabh Banerjee, declared that authorities cannot adopt a discriminatory approach when it comes to granting HRA benefits to personnel of different forces stationed in common areas. This judgment was rendered in response to a series of petitions filed by Group Officers in Grade-A in the Border Security Force (BSF) who were aggrieved by the denial of HRA benefits, which had been limited to Personnel Below Officer Rank (PBOR).
The court's observation in December was poignant, questioning why the Commission had only considered granting parity between PBORs of Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) and those of Defense Forces while neglecting the proposal to extend the same benefits to Coy Commanders, officers at the level of Assistant Commandants and Deputy Commandants. Consequently, the court directed the Central government to extend the HRA benefit to all personnel, irrespective of rank.
The contempt petition pertaining to this matter is scheduled to be heard on November 23, 2023, with Advocate Ankur Chhibber representing the petitioner who initiated the contempt proceedings. On the other side, Central Government Standing Counsel Harish Vaidyanathan and a team of advocates, including Srish Kumar Mishra, Sagar Mehlawat, Alexander Mathai Paikaday, M Sriram, and Krishnan V, represented the Union of India, with Government Pleader Ankit Verma also making an appearance in the case.
🕑 21 Oct, 2024 08:52 PM
Finance Ministry order on July 2024 DA enhancement
🕑 16 Oct, 2024 09:57 PM
Cabinet approves 3% DA hike from July 2023.
🕑 11 Oct, 2024 07:19 PM
Wait for DA hike cabinet approval getting longer
🕑 11 Oct, 2024 07:14 PM
Government Announces New NPS Contribution Guidelines for CG Employees
🕑 11 Oct, 2024 07:02 PM
PM directs action against non-performing or corrupt government employees
🕑 11 Oct, 2024 11:12 AM
Ad-hoc Bonus for 2023-24 for Central Government employees announed
🕑 10 Oct, 2024 05:35 PM
8th Pay Commission may reintroduce DA merger to Basic Pay at 50%
🕑 04 Oct, 2024 09:59 AM
Rate of Interest on GPF and similar funds for Oct-Dec, 2024
🕑 04 Oct, 2024 09:52 AM
Cabinet approves Productivity Linked Bonus for 78 days to railway employees
🕑 04 Oct, 2024 10:05 AM
PFRDA introduces Balanced Life Cycle Fund option
🕑 08 Aug, 2024 11:46 AM
RBI Keeps Key Interest Rate Unchanged to Tackle Inflation
🕑 23 Jun, 2024 08:47 AM
8th Pay Commission: How much pay hike central govt employees expect?
🕑 20 Jun, 2024 05:59 PM
Finance Minister May Increase Income Tax Exemption in Budget 2024
🕑 18 Jun, 2024 03:34 PM
The Impact and Expectations Surrounding the 8th Central Pay Commission
🕑 07 Jun, 2024 10:13 AM
Indian Members of Parliament: Compensation and Benefits
🕑 10 Apr, 2024 08:35 AM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan Admission Guidelines 2024-2025
🕑 05 Apr, 2024 01:23 PM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Balvatika Admission Schedule - 2024-25
🕑 02 Apr, 2024 09:25 AM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Admissions Open for 2024-25: Key Dates & Appln Process