In a recent verdict, the Allahabad High Court declared that employees of autonomous bodies cannot claim identical benefits to government employees simply by the adoption of government service rules, marking a significant distinction between the entitlements of the two categories.
The bench presided over by Justice Abdul Moin addressed a petition requesting directives for an Inter-District Transfer from Bahraich to Unnao. The petitioner, an Assistant Teacher in Bahraich, had sought a transfer, which was initially approved, allowing her to join Unnao. However, subsequent orders reversed the decision, mandating her return to Bahraich.
The primary issue before the court centered on the petitioner's eligibility for a 10-mark weightage based on her husband's employment with the State Government, a criterion mentioned in her transfer application.
Examining Clause 12 of the Government order dated 02.06.2023, the bench delved into constitutional articles such as 309, 310, 311, and 320, emphasizing that individuals considered to serve under the Government or State hold office at the pleasure of the respective executive authorities. Administrative control, recruitment rules, and oversight typically rest with the State Public Service Commission for such roles.
In this case, the petitioner's husband, an employee of Lucknow University—an autonomous body—had rules 'adopted' from the State Government. However, the court highlighted that despite the adoption of these rules, his appointment lacked consultation with the State Public Service Commission, indicating a lack of administrative control by the Governor.
The court clarified that adoption of rules by autonomous bodies does not categorize employees as government servants or under government service. It emphasized that the mere adoption of government rules by autonomous bodies does not grant employees the same entitlements as government employees. The ruling dismissed the petitioner's claims, emphasizing the distinction between government and autonomous body employees in terms of entitlements and benefits.
This verdict sets a precedent, delineating the disparities in benefits between government employees and those in autonomous bodies, based on the mere adoption of government service rules.
🕑 03 May, 2024 12:32 PM
Finance Ministry notifies LIC’s 17% wage revision
🕑 03 May, 2024 10:04 AM
Validity of CGHS empanelled Health Care Organizations (HCO’s) extended
🕑 29 Apr, 2024 09:55 PM
DoPT Clarification on increase in allowances by 25%
🕑 24 Apr, 2024 09:17 AM
DoPT forwards 8th Pay Commission demand by IRTSA forwarded to Fin Min
🕑 23 Apr, 2024 10:01 AM
CGDA: Revision of rates of Allowances with DA rates increased to 50%
🕑 22 Apr, 2024 12:59 PM
CBDT: on DoPT order on regularization of Casual Workers
🕑 21 Apr, 2024 09:54 PM
DoPT Consolidated Instructions on SC, ST, OBC, PwD & EWS reservation
🕑 18 Apr, 2024 11:51 AM
Timeline extended for CGHS Beneficiary ID - ABHA ID linking
🕑 10 Apr, 2024 08:35 AM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan Admission Guidelines 2024-2025
🕑 05 Apr, 2024 01:23 PM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Balvatika Admission Schedule - 2024-25
🕑 02 Apr, 2024 09:25 AM
Kendriya Vidyalaya Admissions Open for 2024-25: Key Dates & Appln Process
🕑 01 Apr, 2024 09:23 AM
Kendriya Vidyalaya (KV) schools where Balvatika is functioning
🕑 14 Mar, 2024 02:07 PM
Govt bans 18 vulgar 18 OTT. See the list here
🕑 08 Mar, 2024 01:49 PM
Pension Scheme Gains Traction Across States, Despite Central Hurdles
🕑 20 Feb, 2024 11:17 PM
CGHS rate for general surgery applicable from February 1, 2024
🕑 08 Feb, 2024 10:19 AM
No loan interst change as RBI maintains repo rate at 6.50% for the 6th time